Roofing Comparison Tool
Compare 134 Products. 15 Brands.
Asphalt shingles, synthetic slate & shake, stone-coated steel, recycled rubber, metal, and more — one tool for every roofing material a St. Louis homeowner could choose. Enter your roof sqft for instant total project estimates.
134 products · 15 brands · 85 shingles · 49 premium alternatives
Not sure which one is right? Talk to a Revolve specialist for a personalized recommendation.
Roofing material questions
- Which roofing material is best for St. Louis hail?
- Class 4 impact-resistant products qualify for 5–30% homeowner insurance discounts in Missouri and Illinois. Options include asphalt shingles (GAF ArmorShield II, OC Duration STORM), synthetic slate (DaVinci, Brava, F-Wave), and stone-coated steel (DECRA, Westlake Royal, Tilcor). Use the Class 4 filter above to see all 80+ options.
- How accurate are the price ranges shown?
- Pricing reflects St. Louis market 2026 estimates including installation, with a 10% waste factor. Enter your roof square footage for personalized total estimates. Final pricing varies by tear-off layers, decking condition, story height, pitch complexity, and material. A Revolve representative confirms the exact price with a free on-site inspection.
- What's the difference between synthetic slate and natural slate?
- Synthetic slate (DaVinci, Brava, F-Wave, EcoStar, Inspire) is a polymer or recycled-content composite that mimics the look of natural quarried slate at 40–60% of the cost and weight. Synthetics are Class 4 hail-rated with 50-year to lifetime warranties. Natural slate has a 75–150 year lifespan but requires structural reinforcement and costs $25–$40/sqft installed.
- What is stone-coated steel roofing?
- Stone-coated steel (DECRA, Westlake Royal Unified Steel, Tilcor) uses a galvanized steel substrate coated with ceramic stone granules. It combines the longevity of metal with the look of tile, shake, or shingle. It's lightweight (~140 lbs/sq vs. 300+ for tile), Class 4 hail-rated, and rated for 120+ mph winds — ideal for St. Louis storms.
